Avoid These 5 Common Mistakes When Choosing Your Guitar Pick as a Beginner

Learning the guitar is an exciting journey filled with discovery, creativity, and a few challenges along the way. While most beginners focus heavily on the guitar itself, they often overlook one of the most important tools in their setup: the guitar pick.

Choosing the wrong pick can slow your progress, make playing less enjoyable, and even cause bad habits. At Rombo Picks, we’ve spent years studying how something as small as a guitar pick can have a huge impact on your playing experience.

Today, we’re going to help you avoid the 5 most common mistakes beginners make when choosing a guitar pick — and set you up for success from your very first strum.

1. Choosing a Pick Based Only on Color or Brand

Mistake:
It’s tempting to grab the coolest-looking pick or the one from a famous brand you recognize. But when you pick a guitar pick based only on its appearance, you ignore critical factors like thickness, material, and shape — all of which have a huge effect on how you play.

Why it matters:
A great pick should feel like an extension of your fingers. If it’s too stiff, too slippery, or poorly shaped for your style, it can hold you back — no matter how good it looks.

Pro Tip:
At Rombo Picks, we design our guitar picks with ergonomic shapes, grip textures, and specialized materials — not just beautiful colors. Choosing a pick designed for performance makes a real difference, even if you're just starting out.

2. Ignoring Pick Thickness and Flexibility

Mistake:
Many beginners grab a random pick without considering how thick or flexible it is. But pick thickness is crucial to how it behaves when it hits the strings.

Why it matters:

• Thin picks (<0.55mm) are great for strumming but offer less control for lead playing.
  

• Medium picks (0.55mm – 1.0mm) balance flexibility and control, making them a good starting point.
  

• Thick picks (over 1 mm) provide precision for soloing, shredding, and technical playing.
  

Pro Tip:
If you’re new, try a medium-thickness pick first. 
We recommend: Rombo Origami

(as we explained in detail here: LINK)

3. Using a Pick That’s Too Slippery or Uncomfortable

Mistake:
A pick that keeps slipping out of your hand or feels awkward to grip can make playing frustrating — and even cause tension in your hand and wrist.

Why it matters:
Grip and comfort are key, especially when you’re developing basic skills. A poor grip leads to inconsistent playing and fatigue.

Pro Tip:
 Look for picks with a textured surface or special grip zones. At Rombo, every pick is designed with a micro-textured surface that provides natural grip, without needing adhesives.

All our picks have variable thickness for extra control, and the surfaces are designed to prevent the pick from rotating while playing (concave and convex 3D shapes).

4. Playing with the Wrong Pick Shape and Size

Mistake:
Not all picks are created equal! Beginners often think all picks are the same size and shape — but the reality is, different shapes can support different techniques.

Why it matters:

• Large picks are easier to hold and control when you’re learning.
  

• Small, sharp picks offer speed and precision but require more finger control.
  

Pro Tip:
If you’re just starting out, a slightly larger pick like Rombo Classic might feel more natural. As you grow, you can experiment with different shapes like sharp tips for speed or triangular picks for versatile playing.

5. Sticking with One Pick Instead of Exploring Options

Mistake:
Many beginners choose one pick and never try anything else, missing out on the incredible variety available today.

Why it matters:
Different picks can unlock different tones, dynamics, and techniques. You might discover that a heavier pick helps your picking speed, or that a softer pick improves your rhythm guitar sound.

Pro Tip:
We always recommend exploration! That’s exactly why Rombo Picks created 12 different pick designs, each with a unique combination of thickness, material, shape, and attack profile. Experimentation keeps your playing fresh and helps you develop your own sound.

🎯 Bonus Tip: Try a Variety Pack to Find Your Perfect Match!

When you're starting out, it’s hard to know exactly which guitar pick will feel right in your hand. That's why trying several styles at once is such a smart move.

The Rombo Variety Pack includes a selection of different shapes, thicknesses, and materials — allowing you to discover what suits your playing style best without guessing.

✅ Explore different grips
✅ Feel the difference between flexible and rigid picks
✅ Find the shape that boosts your confidence

Discover the joy of exploration — and let the right pick find you.

Final Thoughts: The Right Pick Makes a Huge Difference

When you’re just starting to play guitar, small improvements lead to big results. Avoiding these 5 beginner mistakes with guitar picks can save you months of frustration and accelerate your growth.

At Rombo Picks, we’re passionate about creating innovative guitar picks that support every player’s unique journey — whether you’re strumming your first chords or crafting intricate solos.

👉 Explore our collection of ergonomic, sustainable, and beautifully designed guitar picks to find the perfect match for your playing style.

Remember:
The right pick doesn’t just change your playing — it changes how you feel about playing.

Also in Insight ROMBO